Point/Counterpoint: Select committee is laying out a vast Trump conspiracy

From the column: "Americans want to know the truth, they want accountability, and they want concrete actions to prevent an insurrection from happening again."

Patrick Chappatte / Cagle Cartoons
We are part of The Trust Project.

Riveting bipartisan congressional hearings have brought the events on and leading up to the Jan. 6 insurrection to prime time. Compelling evidence shows that then-President Donald Trump carried out a wide-scale conspiracy to overturn the will of the American voters and illegitimately hold onto power. Trump, including his supporters, betrayed the nation while violating his oath of office.

The committee has grounded its work in documenting, substantiating, and sharing the facts. Its work has been guided by nonpartisan career prosecutors who have interviewed 1,000 witnesses and reviewed at least 140,000 documents. The committee has been connecting the dots about the multi-pronged plan to overturn the election. What’s most striking is that, thus far, the committee has almost exclusively presented testimony from senior Republican government officials and operatives — many of them Trump’s closest aides — in their own words.

From the column: "Instead of getting to the bottom of what occurred on Jan. 6, 2021, the committee seems interested only in scoring political points with the public and deterring Trump from potentially running for the presidency again in 2024."

As important, the hearings clarify continuing and future threats to elections. Americans want to know the truth, they want accountability, and they want concrete actions to prevent an insurrection from happening again.

The committee has already clarified a lot.

First, the violent attack on the U.S. Capitol was not spontaneous. It was part of a well-planned and unprecedented power grab that started months earlier — the first-ever attempt by a U.S. president to block the peaceful transition of power. The attack was carried out, in part, by dangerous white supremacists such as the Proud Boys and Oath Keepers who answered Trump’s call to come to Washington and did so armed and prepared for battle. Trump relentlessly pressured his vice president to break the law by refusing to certify the Electoral College result — and, although he now denies it, Trump reportedly supported threats to hang the vice president.


Second, Trump lied to his supporters and the American people after being repeatedly advised that there was zero evidence of wide-scale election fraud. The messengers included Trump’s attorney general, campaign manager and lawyers, and daughter Ivanka Trump who characterized Trump’s baseless arguments as “complete bulls**t” and “crazy stuff.” Every time his advisers debunked a false claim, Trump would resort to another theory as if playing a game of whack-a-mole.

Third, strong evidence shows that Trump and his team likely violated federal laws, including impeding the rightful counting of electoral votes. This builds on a finding from a federal judge that Trump likely committed a crime by attempting to “obstruct the joint session of Congress,” as NPR reported. Regardless of criminality, the facts show that Trump’s actions were a corrupt attack on democracy.

Fourth, the committee has shown that Trump betrayed his supporters. Not only did he knowingly bombard them with disinformation and falsely promise them he would remain president, his campaign also raised $250 million in donations after fraudulently claiming that the money would be spent on a nonexistent election defense fund.

What’s next?

The committee has announced more hearings and plans to release videotaped depositions and other materials. It will also present findings and recommendations in at least one written report, likely by September.

Coming hearings will focus on topics such as Trump’s corrupt plan to replace the U.S. attorney general with someone willing to lie, Trump’s pressure on state and local election officials to change valid election results illegally, and discussions among Trump’s Cabinet to remove him from office because he was unfit.

These hearings, however, are not just about looking in the rearview mirror. The committee must explain the continuing threats to U.S. elections. Trump has not stopped peddling lies or maligning officials who certified lawful election results.

In a worrisome development, numerous candidates are running for statewide positions on a platform of overturning election results. Meanwhile, many states are passing laws — inspired by lies about the 2020 election results — designed to make it harder to vote and easier for partisan officials to sabotage elections. Election officials of both parties continue to receive death threats for properly doing their jobs.


All of this is a recipe for disaster.

That’s why Americans need to demand that officials protect their right to vote and that election lawbreakers be held accountable. Congress must pass legislation making it impossible for future presidents — of either political party — to steal an election. And a robust coalition of conservatives, liberals, and independents must lead the fight to protect democracy. The future of our nation depends on it.

William Roberts is the managing director and Michael Sozan is a senior fellow on the Democracy Policy team at the Center for American Progress, a liberal public policy research and advocacy organization headquartered in Washington, D.C.

William Roberts.jpg
William Roberts
Michael Sozan.jpeg
Michael Sozan

What To Read Next
From the column: "Nobody wants to produce the necessary material for the energy transition at the expense of the natural environment that we all love and enjoy."
From the column: "The challenge reaches far beyond Duluth. There is an urgent need for state and federal resources, on the scale we invest in other aspects of our children’s education."
From the column (sound familiar?): "With its vast and diverse natural resources, Canada is well-positioned to play a critical role in meeting this global demand."
From the column: "Sadly, Holly’s voice had been stilled all too soon. At least his physical voice had. In a larger sense, though, it continued — and grew."