We see that you have javascript disabled. Please enable javascript and refresh the page to continue reading local news. If you feel you have received this message in error, please contact the customer support team at 1-833-248-7801.



COUNTERPOINT: Republicans will benefit, too, from Inflation Reduction Act

From the column: "Republicans simply don't want to let Democrats score points by enacting a signature piece of Biden's domestic agenda, whatever the benefits to their constituents, especially this close to the midterm elections."

Joe Heller
We are part of The Trust Project.

In a polarized America, you don't get this kind of agreement on much of anything.

Three-fourths of voters favor empowering Medicare to bargain with drug companies for lower prices and capping older Americans' drug costs at $2,000 annually. In the same Morning Consult/Politico poll, a similar share supports reducing the federal deficit by up to $300 billion. Roughly three in five voters endorse a minimum tax rate for corporations, tax credits to promote renewable energy, and an extension of health care subsidies for the needy.

The Inflation Reduction Act includes all this and more. So, Republicans, what's not to like?

From the column: "By voting to supersize the IRS, Democrats are directly filling their own campaign war chests."

The 730-page bill may or may not deliver on the inflation promise implied by the Democrats' politically self-serving title for it, but the measure would do plenty that Americans — including Republican voters — like a lot, polls show. Yet not one Senate Republican voted for the package. Not. One. A similar result was expected Friday, when the Democratic-controlled House was expected to pass the bill and send it to President Joe Biden to sign into law.

That Congress would pass a package so full of people-pleasers on a strictly party-line vote is yet another sorry reflection of the state of American politics — and in particular of the Republican Party. How is a nation of 330 million people supposed to solve problems when one of the two major parties is policy-phobic and compromise-averse?


Republicans simply don't want to let Democrats score points by enacting a signature piece of Biden's domestic agenda, whatever the benefits to their constituents, especially this close to the midterm elections. What's more, in a party in which compromise is often a firing offense, Republican lawmakers who cross lines to back a Democratic priority have good reason to fear drawing a challenger in the next Republican primary.

Folks inclined to whataboutism and bothsidesism might counter that, well, in President Donald Trump’s years, Democrats unanimously opposed Republicans' signature accomplishment: the 2017 law that slashed taxes for businesses and wealthy individuals. But that package was opposed by most Americans, by a two-to-one margin, when it passed — and it remains unpopular. (Republicans now damning the Democrats' bill as a budget-buster (which it's not) won't acknowledge this: Their 2017 tax cuts are projected to add as much as $2 trillion to the debt through 2025.)

I'm old enough to remember when Republicans called themselves the party of ideas. Now they're mainly culture warriors. Proposing policies that help people and address chronic domestic problems is no longer their strong suit, to say the least.

What do they promise should they win control of Congress? Investigations of the Justice Department and the FBI, Hunter Biden and Anthony Fauci, all of which promise to be as lengthy, costly, and unproductive as their Benghazi probes of President Barack Obama’s years.

Many Republicans loudly condemned what Sen. Michael D. Crapo of Idaho called "an army of IRS agents" that the Democrats' bill would unleash with an $80-billion infusion for the tax bureau. The unpopular Internal Revenue Service has been so depleted by budget cuts that audits of tax dodgers are rare indeed, and its technology is stuck in the age of paper-processing.

In the years of Presidents Ronald Reagan and George H.W. Bush, Republicans routinely supported providing more money for the IRS in deficit-reduction bills because Congress' nonpartisan scorekeepers rightly ruled that such spending was a revenue raiser: More money meant more agents, more audits, fewer tax evaders, and lower deficits.

Not surprisingly given the demonization of tax collectors since biblical times, the IRS provision is the one element of Democrats' bill that doesn't poll well. Yet the rest adds up to a popular whole, a landmark achievement that probably will help the underdog Democrats in the midterm elections.

Democrats are so jazzed by this and other positive news lately that they've taken to co-opting Republicans' vulgar "Let's go, Brandon" meme applied to the president. They've conjured superhero "Dark Brandon." This Biden is a smiter of Republicans and terrorists, a brandisher of mighty pens to sign major legislation — and a keeper of (most) campaign promises.


Some popular promises — an expanded child tax credit, universal prekindergarten, and higher taxes on the wealthy — were left out to satisfy Democrats' maverick Sens. Joe Manchin III of West Virginia and Kyrsten Sinema of Arizona. Yet here's another thing most Americans agree on, whether in politics or life: You take what you can get.

Jackie Calmes.jpg
Jackie Calmes

What to read next
From the column: "That makes it important to again clearly recognize how the Soviet Union and the United States avoided a nuclear war and kept the Cold War cold."
From the column exclusive to the News Tribune: "Forty years ago when I became a family physician, I took the Hippocratic oath to “do no harm.” Under the direction of Tim Walz, much harm has been inflicted on our state."
From the column exclusive to the News Tribune: "We still have more work to do. We need to expand opportunities for good-paying union jobs, not undermine them."
The Scandia Lutheran Church in Averill, Minnesota, held its last worship service on July 17. It sold off everything that was accumulated in 123 years of service, from the altar to the communion service set to even the metal coat racks that hung in the vestibule.