ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

Proctor teen ruled incompetent to stand trial in Duluth homicide case

Civil commitment proceedings will be initiated for Patrick Wilson Battees Jr., with his juvenile court case suspended until he is deemed fit to stand trial.

battees,patrick 2020.jpg
Patrick Wilson Battees Jr. 2020 handout
We are part of The Trust Project.

A Proctor teen accused of killing a man in Duluth's Central Hillside neighborhood earlier this year has been found incompetent to stand trial.

Judge Jill Eichenwald on Thursday suspended juvenile court proceedings and initiated a civil commitment process for Patrick Wilson Battees Jr., who is charged with the May 22 shooting death of 22-year-old Juamada Keller Anderson Jr.

Battees, who turned 18 in June, has been examined by two psychologists since his arrest. The St. Louis County Attorney's Office objected to the initial findings from Gerald Henkel-Johnson, leading to the court's ordering of a second report from Sara Vaccarella.

PREVIOUSLY: Second mental health evaluation ordered for teen charged in Duluth homicide Patrick Battees, who is said to suffer from schizophrenia, will receive a second opinion from another psychologist before a judge determines whether he is competent to proceed on murder charges stemming from the death of Juamada Anderson.
The actual evaluations are not public, but attorneys indicated Battees was deemed to currently be incapable of understanding the proceedings and taking part in his own defense. No objections were filed to the second evaluation.

Eichenwald ordered that Battees remain at Duluth's Arrowhead Juvenile Center, pending any placement in a treatment facility.

ADVERTISEMENT

"I've seen him pretty much monthly," guardian ad litem Karen Johnson told the court. "He did seem a bit despondent last week — just kind of tired of being there, I guess."

Cases can remain suspended for months or even years before a defendant is determined to be fit to proceed in court. Treatment personnel will be required to file a progress report after six months. If the commitment continues for three years, the case would be dismissed unless the state files a notice of intent to prosecute.

While details of Battees' current health remain unknown, his father reportedly told officials that his son requires medications for schizophrenia and "can become very erratic" when he has not been taking them consistently — which he said had been the case prior to his arrest.

PREVIOUSLY: 2 more charged in connection with Duluth homicide; reports shed new details on shooting Patrick Battees, 17, was seen conversing with Juamada Anderson without incident moments before he allegedly shot the 22-year-old as a fight broke out, according to police reports.
Battees, who prosecutors have hoped to try as an adult, is charged with intentional second-degree murder, unintentional second-degree murder and reckless discharge of a firearm within a municipality.

He is one of five people to be charged in connection with Anderson's killing or the related melee, with four defendants allegedly firing shots amid what police described as a "chaotic" situation.

morris,markus 2021.png
Markus Seville Morris. 2021 handout

Police reports filed in court indicate that Battees and Anderson were conversing on the porch of an apartment building at 118 E. Third St. just before the shooting. The incident, authorities said, escalated after two other men, Markus Seville Morris and Laurel Larice Ladd Jr., were seen pulling into a nearby parking lot and seemingly "forming a plan."

ADVERTISEMENT

Video allegedly shows Morris, 31, walking up to Battees on the porch and demonstrating "pre-attack cues by sizing up Battees and pulling his shorts up." Anderson can then be seen getting between the two men before Morris pushes him against the railing, the reports state.

Investigators said Ladd, 26, could then be seen entering the confrontation and punching Battees. As the scuffle moved toward the sidewalk, Ladd reportedly could be seen handing an item — which investigators believe to be a gun — to Morris.

ladd,laurel 2021.png
Laurel Larice Ladd Jr. 2021 handout

Battees is then allegedly seen taking out his own firearm and shooting, striking Anderson as the crowd begins to disperse. Video allegedly shows Morris pointing his gun and shooting at Battees before handing the weapon back to Ladd. Police said Battees fled the scene but was arrested a few blocks away after stashing his gun in a discarded couch.

Investigators subsequently indicated the incident may have been linked to a 2020 shooting that reportedly injured a relative of Ladd. Battees was not charged with the shooting itself, but did serve a nine-month jail sentence in Douglas County after leading police on a resulting high-speed chase.

One co-defendant, 35-year-old Tyrone Deshun Childs Sr., who reportedly fired a handgun from inside a van parked across the street from the crime scene, entered a guilty plea in September to counts of drive-by shooting and being a felon in possession of a firearm. His sentencing is set for Dec. 6.

ADVERTISEMENT

Tyrone Deshun Childs 2021.jpg
Tyrone Deshun Childs. 2020 handout

Another suspect, Eddie Ezra Conyers Jr., 17, was recently certified to stand trial as an adult on several firearm-related charges. He allegedly told police that he "wanted to see a fight" and shot off five rounds. He is scheduled to be back in court Monday.

Ladd faces a Nov. 5 court date, while Morris is slated to appear Nov. 12.

Eddie Ezra Conyers Jr 2021.jpg
Eddie Ezra Conyers Jr.

Tom Olsen has covered crime and courts for the Duluth News Tribune since 2013. He is a graduate of the University of Minnesota Duluth and a lifelong resident of the city. Readers can contact Olsen at 218-723-5333 or tolsen@duluthnews.com.
What to read next
On today’s episodes, researchers see how a warmer climate affects trees, a crisis shelter for pets, and more.
Bygones is researched and written by David Ouse, retired reference librarian from the Duluth Public Library. He can be contacted at djouse49@gmail.com.
Peggy Floding will appear in court next month on three felony charges stemming from the July crash that injured Nancy Waters.
The move extends the company's reach beyond its existing goal of opening an underground mine in Aitkin County.