ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

With billions unspent, Minnesota lawmakers race the clock to decide top needs

Tax cuts, hero pay, money for police and schools: Here's a recap of where some top policy and spending proposals stand in the Legislature as lawmakers return home for a one-week recess.

Minnesota Senate - 013122
Members of the Minnesota Senate on Monday, Jan. 31, 2022, applauded after Sen. Dave Osmek, R-Mound, was elected as Senate president on the first day of the 2022 legislative session.
Dana Ferguson / Forum News Service

ST. PAUL — Minnesotans could receive rebate checks or see their taxes slashed.

Police departments around the state could get funding to help them scale up staffing to respond to mounting crime.

And customers could again be able to buy growlers from a handful of the state's biggest breweries.

As the state Legislature enters the home stretch of the 2022 session, billions of dollars of budget surplus money are at stake.

The number of issues that can be debated still is constrained and could dim the prospects for legislation on issues such as legal sports betting and loosening restrictions on growler sales in the state.

Over the first two months of the legislative session, lawmakers in the divided Legislature have set the goalposts for their priorities, leaving some expansive gaps between DFL and GOP plans. And when they get back from a one-week break on April 19, they’ll enter a month of swift legislative action and (likely) tough negotiations about what can appease both Democrats and Republicans at the Capitol.

ADVERTISEMENT

As lawmakers go home for the 2022 legislative recess this week, here’s a look at where some of the biggest issues stand.

Sen. Carla Nelson, R-Rochester
Minnesota Sen. Carla Nelson, R-Rochester, on Feb. 24, 2022, introduces a Senate proposal to cut the state's lowest income tax bracket and to drop the tax on social security benefits during a news conference at the Minnesota Capitol complex.
Dana Ferguson / Forum News Service

Tax cuts or rebate checks

Just ahead of the legislative recess, the GOP-led Senate approved and the DFL-led House introduced their tax bills, complete with a nearly $7 billion split between them.

Republican priorities included cutting the lowest tier of the state’s income tax, eliminating the tax on social security benefits and conforming the state tax code to federal law. Meanwhile, Democrats said they would take a more targeted approach that included tax credits and rebates for child care, renters and homestead credits and a bigger student loan tax credit.

Rep. Paul Marquart
State Rep. Paul Marquart, DFL-Dilworth, on Tuesday, April 5, 2022, speaks with reporters at the Minnesota Capitol about the House Democratic-Farmer-Labor tax bill and other priorities.
Dana Ferguson / Forum News Service

If approved, the Senate GOP plan would cost $3.3 billion next year and $5 billion in the two years that follow. The DFL proposal would come with a $1.65 billion price tag in the first year and $1.6 billion in the next two years.

Neither tax plan included a proposal from Gov. Tim Walz to pay out $500 in direct payments to taxpayers that earn under a certain threshold. Negotiations about a final tax plan are likely to continue when legislators return to St. Paul.

Crime scene
An investigator with the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension crime scene team photographs the interior of a garage on the property where Cristyna Watson of Floodwood was discovered Oct. 4. (Clint Austin / caustin@duluthnews.com)

Public safety and police recruitment

Both Republicans and Democrats said that reducing violent crime and improving public safety would be a top priority this year. And they’ve laid out different plans to accomplish that.

ADVERTISEMENT

Senate Republicans pitched a $65 million package to help recruit more law enforcement officers around the state and they proposed setting tougher penalties for carjackers and those who commit a violent offense with a weapon.

In an effort to prevent criminal offenders from committing additional crimes, they’ve also advanced legislation to require prosecutors to bring charges against offenders in certain cases. If they don’t, the prosecutors could face misdemeanor charges, under the bill.

032622.N.FNS.DFLSAFETYPLAN - Carlos Mariani
Minnesota Rep. Carlos Mariani, DFL-St. Paul, on Thursday, March 24, 2022, speaks with the reporters at the Capitol about at Democratic proposal to fund public safety and community group responses to prevent and respond to crime in Minnesota.
Dana Ferguson / Forum News Service

By contrast, House Democrats proposed a heftier $150 million public safety bill with targeted funding aimed at helping communities around the state with the highest rates of violence and increasing crime. The plan attempts to address root causes of violent crime such as offering diversion programs for juvenile offenders and relying on community groups to deter violence.

Both Democrats and Republicans have proposed boosting funding to public defenders in the state, who threatened to strike in March and ultimately renegotiated their contracts after they raised concerns about inadequate staffing and excessive caseloads.

Sen. Roger Chamberlain - Parents bill of rights
Sen. Roger Chamberlain, R-Lino Lakes, on Monday, Feb. 14, 2022, speaks with reporters at the Minnesota Capitol about a slate of bills Republicans put forward to ensure parents were up to date on what students are taught in Minnesota public schools.
Dana Ferguson / Forum News Service

Education and K-12 schools

House Democrats and Senate Republicans in the days before the legislative break rolled out plans for education funding that are billions of dollars apart.

DFL lawmakers proposed spending an additional $1 billion in the coming budget year, and more than $2 billion in the following two years to boost Minnesota schools. The biggest spending provisions would build out mental health services, including counselors, for public schools and add $500 million in support for special education and English language learner programs in the next three years.

By contrast, Republicans in the Senate put forward a $30 million supplement for schools that would focus on training elementary school teachers in new strategies to teach reading. They have also passed several pieces of their proposed " Parents Bill of Rights " that would require teachers to make learning materials available to parents.

ADVERTISEMENT

Conversations about a compromise plan are set to start later this month.

Sen. Eric Pratt, UI Trust Fun
Minnesota Sen. Eric Pratt, along with other lawmakers and business leaders on Monday, Feb. 7, 2022, speaks to reporters at the Capitol about a $2.73 billion plan to repay the federal government and replenish the state's unemployment trust fund.
Dana Ferguson / Forum News Service

Unemployment trust fund, payroll tax

Legislative leaders and the governor remained in negotiations this month about a compromise that could refill the state’s unemployment insurance trust fund and counteract a payroll tax hike on employers.

Lawmakers in March missed a deadline to repay the federal government $1 billion for sending Minnesota resources to help those who were out of a job during the pandemic. They also disagreed on how much the state should spend to replenish the jobless fund.

The Senate in February advanced a $2.7 billion plan to repay the federal government the $1 billion and to replenish the fund to prevent a tax hike for Minnesota employers. Walz also supported that plan. But the House countered with a less expensive proposal that would repay the federal government but not fully replenish the state’s fund.

Legislative leaders met for weeks in an attempt to strike a deal but have so far failed to agree.

dsc09944.jfif
Rep. Cedrick Frazier, DFL-New Hope, on the floor of the Minnesota House of Representatives Thursday, Feb. 24, 2022, discussing his proposal to give a total of $1 billion to workers who reported to their jobs during the pandemic.
Alex Derosier / Forum News Service

Checks for front-line workers

The Minnesota House ahead of the recess passed a $ 1 billion plan to send $1,500 checks out to front-line workers who stayed on the job during the pandemic. But Senate leaders said they’re not interested in the plan.

During closed negotiations about the hero paychecks and a plan to repay the state’s unemployment insurance trust fund, Senate Majority Leader Jeremy Miller, R-Winona, offered to let House members decide how $250 million in hero paychecks would be sent out. But that was contingent on House leaders agreeing to pass a $2.7 billion proposal to repay the federal government and replenish the state’s unemployment trust fund.

House Speaker Melissa Hortman, DFL-Brooklyn Park, rejected that offer and said it was a step backward since the Legislature last year approved $250 million for the hero paychecks but lawmakers never agreed on how to disburse them.

Bernie Burnham, with the Duluth Federation of Teachers, talks about the importance of sick and safe time to a family when a child gets sick and can't be in school. She spoke to a crowd of some 50 people who came to support the earned sick and safe time measure under consideration by the Duluth City Council on Monday night. Bob King / rking@duluthnews.com
Bernie Burnham, with the Duluth Federation of Teachers, talks about the importance of sick and safe time to a family when a child gets sick and can't be in school. She spoke to a crowd of some 50 people who came to support the earned sick and safe time measure under consideration by the Duluth City Council on Monday night. Bob King / rking@duluthnews.com

Paid family leave, sick and safe time

For the first time this year, Republicans introduced a plan to set up paid family leave benefits for Minnesota workers. And it focused more on allowing businesses to opt in to the benefit rather than creating a new state program for workers.

The GOP proposal would rewrite state law to let insurers offer paid family and medical leave insurance plans to business owners and it would create a small business tax credit for each employee that enrolls in the program. Republicans said the changes would help more workers access the benefits without overburdening employers with the cost of a new program.

Democrats at the Capitol for years have encouraged the creation of a state program that would offer up to 12 weeks of partially paid time off for pregnancy, serious health conditions, family care, leave when a family member is called for active military duty and safety leave for domestic abuse situations. Each Minnesotan would contribute about $3 per week to the state program. The amount of pay a beneficiary receives would be based on a sliding scale.

While Democrats and Republicans disagree on the best approach, having both sides at the table could help to reach a compromise.

Meanwhile, a proposal to create a paid sick and safe time program that would allow workers to accrue up to 48 hours of time off each passed the Minnesota House but so far has not found support in the Minnesota Senate.

WALZ 012622.JPG
Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz presents his administration's supplemental budget recommendations Wednesday, Jan. 26, to reporters at a news conference at the Department of Revenue in St. Paul.
Alex Derosier / Forum News Service

Bonding bill for local projects

While even-numbered years at the Capitol are typically known as bonding years, where lawmakers focus their attention on a borrowing bill that can fund local projects all around the state, that issue has taken a back seat this year to the historic $9.25 billion surplus.

The chair of the Senate Capital Investment Committee last week asked lawmakers on that panel to vet local projects that would be top priority before the final stretch of the legislative session. Meanwhile, House Capital Investment Committee members have heard testimony on dozens of proposed projects that could encompass a state jobs and projects bill.

Both committees have toured hundreds of proposed project sites around Minnesota in the last two years. And they’re expected to advance their lists of priority construction projects in coming weeks.

Local governments and state agencies ahead of the legislative session put in bids that totaled more than $5.4 billion dollars. And state economists said Minnesota had capacity to borrow up to $3.5 billion to fund proposed projects. Walz earlier this year requested a $2.7 billion bonding bill.

1621671+033015.N.WCT_.AVIANFLU.jpg
The highly pathogenic avian influenza has struck a third commercial turkey flock in Minnesota, this time in Stearns County. The county is the state’s second highest producer of poultry behind Kandiyohi County. (Submitted photo)

Drought relief and bird flu resources

Both chambers of the Legislature on Thursday, April 7, approved $1 million in emergency support to help the Minnesota Department of Agriculture manage the highly pathogenic avian influenza. So far, the illness that is contagious for birds has been detected in 21 Minnesota flocks, affecting 1 million birds.

Agriculture committee leaders were also set to meet after the legislative recess to iron out differences between their proposals to send out $10 million or more in aid to farmers and ranchers.

Both chambers approved plans to issue grants and loans to specialty crop farmers and ranchers that were hit hardest by the 2021 drought conditions, but differences in the bills set them up for a conference committee to decide which pieces of each should move forward.

As of this week, highly pathogenic avian influenza has been found in 24 states and has resulted in the death of 23 million birds.

The Senate tacked on to its proposal additional funds for the Minnesota Veterinary Diagnostic lab to purchase new equipment to aid in detecting avian influenza and limiting its spread. The plan would also set aside emergency funds for the Department of Agriculture to address that illness or others affecting Minnesota flocks.

House lawmakers, meanwhile, included a $13 million provision that would create grants to replace trees and seedlings destroyed by the drought conditions and to build up water infrastructure.

Growlers sit in a cooler at the Castle Danger Brewery taproom. Steve Kuchera / skuchera@duluthnews.com
Growlers sit in a cooler at the Castle Danger Brewery taproom. Steve Kuchera / skuchera@duluthnews.com

‘Free the growler’ provision still in play

A Minnesota House committee before the legislative deadline approved a broad liquor bill that would allow breweries that produced up to 150,000 barrels a year to offer growler sales, up from the current 20,000 barrel cap.

That cap prevented the state's six largest craft breweries — Castle Danger, Fulton, Indeed, Lift Bridge, Schell's and Surly — from selling growlers.

Stakeholders including craft beverage producers, wholesalers, liquor retailers and Teamsters met in private for months to hammer out an agreement. And they told lawmakers that the plan had pieces that they could all get behind.

A key Senate gatekeeper, Commerce Committee Chair Gary Dahms, R-Redwood Falls, on March 31 said he’d not yet read the proposal but had previously said he’d only bring up bills for consideration that had support from all stakeholders involved.

A liquor bill that has cleared one House committee would permit broader sales of 64-ounce growlers and, to a lesser degree, six packs at breweries as well as bottles of alcohol at distilleries.

Follow Dana Ferguson on Twitter  @bydanaferguson , call 651-290-0707 or email  dferguson@forumcomm.com.

Dana Ferguson is a Minnesota Capitol Correspondent for Forum News Service. Ferguson has covered state government and political stories since she joined the news service in 2018, reporting on the state's response to the COVID-19 pandemic, the divided Statehouse and the 2020 election.
What To Read Next
The Beltrami County Jail has been ordered to reduce inmate capacity after a Minnesota DOC investigation showed that the jail's minimum staffing requirements were not met on several occasions.
The “Driver’s Licenses For All” bill would remove the requirement for license applicants to provide proof of citizenship or lawful presence.
Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison repeated his concern that the planned March 31 merger date is "too ambitious."
In a letter to state officials, the company said the closure would be permanent, but did not explain its decision to the state