ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

Court: Minnesota must refund restitution to stripper whose blackmail conviction was vacated

The case involves Bunny Byington, who admitted in Clay County District Court in September 2009 that she threatened to expose a pastor who paid her for nude dancing and sex unless he provided her with thousands of dollars in hush money.

FSA Minnesota supreme court
The chambers of the Minnesota Supreme Court.
Forum News Service file photo
We are part of The Trust Project.

MOORHEAD, Minn. — The Minnesota Supreme Court has ruled the state of Minnesota must pay thousands of dollars to a stripper whose 2009 conviction for blackmailing a pastor she had sex with was vacated after the law she was charged under was deemed unconstitutional.

The case involves Bunny Byington, who admitted in Clay County District Court in September 2009 that she threatened to expose a Valley City, North Dakota, pastor who paid her for nude dancing and sex unless he provided her with thousands of dollars in hush money. At the time, Byington was a stripper in Moorhead.

According to court documents, the pastor paid Byington about $7,000 that she demanded from him, but after he refused to pay her an additional $18,000, she contacted his wife and church officials.

The pastor ultimately resigned from his job.

In October 2009, Byington was sentenced for her conviction on a charge of coercion to 90 days in jail and 10 years of probation.

ADVERTISEMENT

She was also ordered to pay restitution of about $7,000 to the pastor and about $5,800 to Clay County Social Services for welfare payments the county said she was not entitled to because she didn't disclose income she received from the pastor.

After Byington completed her probation in 2019, the Minnesota Court of Appeals ruled in a separate case that the statute Byington was convicted of violating was so broad it violated the First Amendment.

Byington then filed a petition with the district court for post-conviction relief, seeking to have her conviction and sentence vacated.

Her petition was later amended to ask that the district court also order any restitution she paid be refunded to her.

The district court agreed that Byington's conviction and sentence should be vacated.

However, the court maintained that while Byington was legally entitled to a refund of the restitution she paid, the court said it lacked authority to specify who must pay back the money and how the payment would be secured.

The Minnesota Court of Appeals upheld the district court decision, but the Minnesota Supreme Court ruled the case should be returned to the district court to determine what restitution refund Byington is owed.

"Payments Byington made to CCSS and the victim should be credited toward restitution on remand because she was ordered to pay this restitution as part of her sentence for a conviction that has been invalidated," the Supreme Court said in its ruling, adding that the state of Minnesota will be responsible to pay whatever amount is owed.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Supreme Court ruling noted, however, that the record is unclear as to how much Byington actually paid in restitution.

Clay County Social Services credits Byington with having paid $2,725 in restitution, but there is no accounting for how much she paid to the pastor or how much she paid in fines and fees, the Supreme Court said.

The court noted Byington asserts about $10,000 went toward restitution, but she has not specified how much of that amount was credited toward restitution, as opposed to fines and fees.

Clay County Attorney Brian Melton said the Supreme Court ruling makes clear the "taxpayers of Minnesota would be forced to pay" for the restitution refund, but precisely where the money will come from is not spelled out.

"It would have to come out of some state agency, not sure what agency that would be, which was one of the points the state was making," Melton said.

"There is no specific agency that would be responsible, so it could be anything from the governor’s office to taking it out of the Minnesota Supreme Court’s budget," he added.

I'm a reporter and a photographer and sometimes I create videos to go with my stories.

I graduated from Minnesota State University Moorhead and in my time with The Forum I have covered a number of beats, from cops and courts to business and education.

I've also written about UFOs, ghosts, dinosaur bones and the planet Pluto.

You may reach me by phone at 701-241-5555, or by email at dolson@forumcomm.com
What To Read Next
North Dakota officials are preparing to file a lawsuit against Minnesota on the grounds that the law interferes with their ability to sell coal and natural gas.
A family of five was shot to death by Neil M. Pladson in 1970. Pladson was imprisoned, then released to a halfway house in 1987. A year later, he was found strangled to death in his apartment.
As winter cold bites deep, MPR News is celebrating the best of the season through a new series called Winter Play.
Attorney General Keith Ellison says he’s been asking the Legislature for years to give him more funding for the criminal division of his office.