Tough contract negotiations linger over US Steel's Keetac celebration

United Steelworkers held a demonstration outside the mine, where company and state officials touted the planned $150 million DR-grade pellet plant.

man in suit talks to man in t-shirt
Gov. Tim Walz, left, talks with Bill Fredette, Sr. while visiting with members of the local chapter of the United Steelworkers after a celebration marking the construction of a $150 million direct-reduced-grade pellet plant Wednesday at U.S. Steel Keetac in Keewatin.
Clint Austin / Duluth News Tribune
We are part of The Trust Project.

KEEWATIN, Minn. — Top U.S. Steel officials descended on the Keetac iron ore mine and pellet processing plant Wednesday to celebrate starting construction on a $150 million direct-reduced-grade iron pellet plant.

But the event, attended by Gov. Tim Walz and many of his commissioners, was overshadowed by the Pittsburgh-based company’s tense contract negotiations with the United Steelworkers, which represents employees at the company’s Minntac and Keetac iron ore mines and pellet plants in Mountain Iron and Keewatin, respectively.

man in suit talks with people during event in Keewatin
Gov. Tim Walz, center, talks to members of the United Steelworkers after attending a celebration marking the construction of a $150 million direct-reduced-grade pellet plant in Keewatin on Wednesday.
Clint Austin / Duluth News Tribune

John Arbogast, USW District 11 staff representative, said the union was invited to participate in Wednesday’s event but chose not to.

“It’s sad U.S. Steel planned this celebration when we’re in the middle of a contract war. … I would love to be there. We all would. This is very exciting news for the Iron Range,” Arbogast said of the DR-grade plant. “This is huge.”

people gathered outside during event in Keewatin
Members and supporters of the United Steelworkers gather for an informational picket outside their Keewatin union hall Wednesday.
Clint Austin / Duluth News Tribune

Instead, union members gathered at the intersection outside the union hall in downtown Keewatin and along the road to Keetac, with some signs reading “FDB” — or "Fair Deal Burritt."


U.S Steel CEO Dave Burritt would not speak with the press after Wednesday’s event.

But through a spokesperson, the company said in a statement: “We appreciate our employees’ dedication and respect their right to assemble. We continue to bargain with the USW in good faith and remain optimistic that we will reach an agreement that is best for all.”

Man raises hands while speaking during event in Keewatin
David Burritt, president and CEO of U.S. Steel, speaks during a celebration marking the construction of a $150 million direct-reduced-grade pellet plant Wednesday at U.S. Steel Keetac.
Clint Austin / Duluth News Tribune

A sign of the tense negotiations, U.S. Steel last week filed a complaint with the National Labor Relations Board alleging USW was failing to bargain.

In a text updating members on negotiations, USW called the charges “frivolous.”

Union Local presidents are headed to Pittsburgh to resume negotiations Thursday. The current contract has been extended since Aug. 30.

cars decorated with signs during event in Keewatin
Vehicles decorated with picket signs line the street leading to Keetac during a celebration marking the construction of a $150 million direct-reduced-grade pellet plant Wednesday. The vehicles were on the route taken by David Burritt, president and CEO of U.S. Steel, on his way to the event.
Clint Austin / Duluth News Tribune

Another rally is planned for Saturday in Virginia. USW members and supporters are gathering at 10 a.m. at the east end of Chestnut Street East near the intersection with the Mesabi Trail before marching to Veterans Memorial Park, 403 First St. N., for a picnic and speakers.

‘We’re miles apart’

The other iron mining company on the Iron Range, Cleveland-Cliffs, has already wrapped up negotiations with USW. Workers at two of its three USW-represented mines in Minnesota ratified their new contract last week with the third expected to vote on it this month.

The contract with Cliffs is being held up by USW as the example for U.S. Steel to follow, and Arbogast said union negotiations are pushing for what’s in the Cliffs contract: a 20% raise over the contract’s four-year term and $4 billion in USW-represented facilities during the contract.


men in suits look at bottles during event in Keewatin
Mike Bakk, right, with U.S. Steel, shows Gov. Tim Walz samples of the new pellet Wednesday.
Clint Austin / Duluth News Tribune

But currently, the proposal by U.S. Steel is a 14% raise over four years and $1 billion in facility upgrades over that time period.

The Cliffs contract also got a sixth week of vacation, parental leave for both parents, recognition of Juneteenth as a holiday and language for victims of domestic abuse.

Additionally, Arbogast said U.S. Steel’s health care would take Mayo Clinic and Essentia Health, the region’s major health care provider, out of network.

“We are so far apart from where Cliffs is, with our pattern that’s been established … we’re not even close, we’re miles apart on wages, pensions, health care, holidays … we got to get what Cliffs got,” Arbogast said.

decorated vehicle during event in Keewatin
An SUV sits with requests for a fair contract for the United Steelworkers prior to a celebration marking the construction $150 million direct-reduced-grade pellet plant Wednesday in Keewatin. The letters “FDB” stand for "Fair Deal Burritt," referring to the president and CEO of U.S. Steel, David Burritt.
Clint Austin / Duluth News Tribune

Keetac truck drivers Debra Wilson and Sam Sampsell, both single mothers, said a fair contract was important, especially after years of 12-hour shifts, overnight shifts and forced overtime.

“I think this is the hardest I've ever worked in my life,” Sampsell said. “But it's also the most beneficial at the same time, and I think that's a hard thing to have at risk.”

“We’ve worked our butts off,” Wilson said.

After Wednesday’s event, Gov. Tim Walz visited the USW members in Keewatin. He told the News Tribune the negotiation “process has to play out," but he said he told Burritt the USW is “the world’s best workforce.”


“The process is working,” Walz said. “They're collectively bargaining for a good contract. I think certainly Dave (Burritt) knows that your workforce is your gold up here. And so I fully expect they'll get a good contract.”

Both the temporary and permanent fixes could see changes to prevent the spread of the invasive species.
We may pay a little more in taxes than people in some other states, but our investment is returning big dividends in the education of our students.
From the column: "Did this 'incomprehensible rate of advancement' that we’ve seen in virtually every aspect of our lives over the last 50 years somehow skip over the mining industry? Thankfully, it did not."
The Republican candidate for governor called for supporting copper-nickel mining in northern Minnesota, a controversial practice that could bring many high-paying jobs to the region but threaten to pollute its water resources.
This News Tribune endorsement was determined solely by the News Tribune Editorial Board.
The plan would move processing facilities and tailings storage away from Talon’s proposed underground mine near Tamarack and into North Dakota.
From the column: "Minerals right here in Minnesota can help meet consumer demand and bring manufacturing and jobs back to America. ... Minerals like copper are critical to the clean-energy transition."
Some candidates in districts 3 and 8 believe copper-nickel sulfide mines can operate safely, while others say the environmental risk is too great.
The company behind the long-stalled and half-built iron ore mine and processing facility near Nashwauk failed to make a $200 million payment in a last-chance requirement set by the DNR.
From the column: "I believe we have a great future here in the Northland. ... First, we must support all mining in our region."

DR-grade pellet plant

Construction has already started on the facility, which is expected to be operational in late 2023 and the first pellets produced in 2024, the company said.

Keetac has traditionally produced pellets for blast furnaces, but DR-grade pellets — with less silica and more iron — can serve as feedstock when making direct-reduced iron or hot-briquetted iron, which in turn supply electric arc furnaces making steel.

Electric furnaces are becoming more common in the steelmaking industry and use less carbon than blast furnaces.

Burritt said it “takes down the carbon footprint and creates jobs through feast and famine.”

Decorated sign during event in Keewatin
A decorated vehicle asks for a fair deal for the United Steelworkers from David Burritt, president and CEO of U.S. Steel, during an informational picket in downtown Keewatin on Wednesday.
Clint Austin / Duluth News Tribune

When the steel industry slumps, Keetac has long been the first U.S. Steel facility on the Iron Range to close and the last to reopen when it improves.

But the hope is that the new plant will help reduce those idlings and keep Keetac’s approximately 400 employees working.

“When we build this facility, what this does is it levels out those peaks and valleys,” Burritt said.

It’s a hope shared by the union.

“The fact that Keetac is going to be technologically moving into the next century, this will secure Keetac’s future where they won't have to be a swing facility and live by the up and downs,” Arbogast said.

Jimmy Lovrien covers energy, mining and the 8th Congressional District for the Duluth News Tribune. He can be reached at or 218-723-5332.
What to read next
The victim suffered at least six wounds and a collapsed lung in the Gary-New Duluth attack.
The incident started at Minnesota Power headquarters, went across the Bong Bridge to Superior and back to Duluth via the Oliver Bridge before a 70 mph collision along snowy roads.
Also on today’s episode, a Duluth man is charged after a cross-bridge stolen truck pursuit ends in crash.
Bygones is researched and written by David Ouse, retired reference librarian from the Duluth Public Library. He can be contacted at