After four attempts to bring its "Raise Our Standards" event to Duluth, the Center of the American Experiment presented its program on pushing back against critical race theory to an audience of about 30 inside the Lafayette Community Center on Tuesday, June 13. Outside, a gathering of about 40 protesters showed their disapproval of the event.
Four different locations including the Northland Country Club, the Holiday Inn and Suites Duluth, the AAD Shrine Event Center and the Cast Iron Bar and Grill canceled the event before it shifted to the community center on Park Point. It was originally scheduled to take place on June 17 in the middle of the organization's 17-city speaking tour, which wrapped up June 30.
Critical race theory is a framework developed by legal scholars in the 1970s as a response to persisting evidence of racism in the wake of the Civil Rights Movement in the 1950s and 1960s. It examines the enduring legacies of racism in the U.S.
Before the event, protesters gathered along Minnesota Avenue with flags and signs promoting racial justice. One of the organizers of the protest, Sam Nelson of Superior, said she was there as a parent of two girls.
"I think the U.S. has a really bad track record of telling the truth and whitewashing history," Nelson said. "We leave a lot of important things out when we teach our kids. It's important for me to teach my kids the truth and for them to understand why things are the way they are so they can make the changes necessary to make the world a more equitable place."
Protesters moved from Minnesota Avenue to the stairs outside of the venue while the presentation got underway at 5:30 p.m. A few police officers were stationed inside and a few more arrived when protesters grew a little loud at points throughout the presentation.
- Critical race theory debate makes its way to Carlton County
- Stauber tweets out against critical race theory
Kendall Qualls, former Minnesota Congressional candidate and founder of TakeCharge, claimed the disintegration of the family, especially for Black Americans, is responsible for a lot of the issues in today’s society.
“Are there racists out there in this country? You bet. But is America a racist country? Emphatically no,” Qualls said.
Qualls argued that teaching critical race theory in schools “belittles the progress that has been made in the country over generations” and that whole families with two parents is what makes a greater difference when bridging the gap between disparities.
Then John Hinderaker presented the center’s views on critical race theory.
“Those knuckleheads outside would call us racist for talking about this, which is ironic because this presentation that I’m about to present to you was created by Catrin Wigfall who is married to a Black man,” Hinderaker said.
Normally the presentation given by Hinderaker is presented by Catrin Wigfall of the Center of the American Experiment, but as she is currently seven months pregnant, Hinderaker gave the presentation in her stead.
He argued that critical race theory is not “just an academic discipline but a way to fundamentally transform the way children are taught about our society.”
As Hinderaker presented, a few people in the room mumbled under their breath in disagreement to some of his points. One such person was UMD student Tom Julstrom of St. Cloud. Julstrom said he attended the meeting to hear what the organization was saying about the topic.
“It was a remarkable misrepresentation of a number of things,” Julstrom said. “I’m just flabbergasted at the amount of fairly straightforward facts that they’ve wrapped up and twisted to suit their message. But it was a fun way to spend an afternoon.”
Greg Cooper of Duluth also attended the event to hear what the organization had to say, and sided with the presenters' claims in the end.
"I’ve been hearing a lot about the topic and I wanted to get another perspective on it,” Cooper said. “It seems like they’re removing huge chunks of history which would dramatically impact how our children learn. It seems like a pretty radical shift from what I was taught back in the day and it breaks my heart to learn about it.”
Some states have introduced legislation banning public schools from promoting critical race theory, including six that have enacted laws. Last month, the Minnesota Department of Education addressed the topic in a statement to the News Tribune, which starts by saying critical race theory isn't included in the state's K-12 academic standards, or in any proposed ones.
The event wrapped up around 6:30, and protesters remained in place along the exit as attendees made their way out.
A more in-depth analysis of the presentation by the Center of the American Experiment is slated for publication later this week.