I was reading a novel recently and found myself admiring some punctuation. It was a single-quote, comma, quote mark sequence at the end of a sentence, and it had me feeling satisfied, thinking, āThis book is well-edited.ā
Later, there was a sentence in italics, and a word within the sentence was italicized by not being in italics. I nodded my head a little in approval. āYes,ā I thought, āI like it when thatās done that way. Thatās how it should be.ā
The excitement of the story was lost on me for a few moments as I copy-edited the book.
Itās a hard thing to turn off when you work as an editor. I suspect most editors read a little slower than the average person, hoping to see mistakes and being frequently annoyed when things are not the way we think they should be.
I could be reading the latest best-seller, a murder mystery or epic romance but be distracted by the thought, āāCancelledā with two lās is the secondary spelling in Websterās Dictionary. I donāt like that.ā
Iāll even look up words, questioning if a different word might have been better. Or looking to see whether my understanding of a word might be imprecise, and I want to know for sure exactly what it means.
āWhy did the author use āaplombā when āpoiseā would do? Why write āhirsuteā instead of āhairyā?ā
These are the kinds of things you think when you edit a daily newspaper, where we tend to eschew - or avoid, that is - five-dollar words. Itās a wonder my vocabulary isnāt better, given all the word-looking-upping, but Iām no English major, after all.
Itās a shame that a love of reading, a love of writing - a love of language - could lead a person into a profession where that love becomes a chore. It invades my private life, making leisure reading less leisurely. Even Facebook posts can cause anxiety because some of my friends are editors, too, and they will notice my mistakes.
I imagine all professions are plagued by this, however. Are hairdressers always too keenly aware of bad haircuts? Do police officers go a little crazy witnessing the bad driving they see only when theyāre not in squad cars? Do construction workers white-knuckle it as they drive by a house where it looks like the deck might collapse any moment? And maybe they think, āIād love my job if it werenāt for all the hair cutting - or driving around - or building stuff.ā
I know there are days I like my job just fine - except for all the reading. Iād call it a cruel irony, but copy editors donāt like cliches, either. Oh well.
Beverly Godfrey is a News Tribune columnist and copy editor. You can reach her at bgodfrey@duluthnews.com .