More asbestos-like fibers have been discovered in rock samples from the Penokee Hills of Northwestern Wisconsin, where a company had proposed to build an open-pit iron mine.

According to a northern Wisconsin geoscientist, the greatest amounts of hazardous minerals are in the western part of the range, including the area that mining outfit Gogebic Taconite planned to develop before pulling out of the project earlier this year.

Newsletter signup for email alerts

Northland College associate professor of geoscience Tom Fitz said there's an approximately nine-mile stretch of the range with rock containing the long, slender "asbestiform" crystals. The crystals are a form of mineral known to be linked to mesothelioma, a rare type of lung cancer.

"In the stretch that's in Wisconsin between the western part of the Penokee Range over to Ironwood, the area near Mellen, is the area that has the greatest potential to have the asbestiform variety," Fitz said.

He said the asbestiform minerals show up in the Tyler Forks River and become abundant in some areas between there and southwest of Mellen.

Differences in geologic heat when the minerals were formed account for the variation in some parts of the range, Fitz explained. Not all so-called amphibole minerals are known to be hazardous, he said - just those that got hot enough to form into the long, slender asbestiform crystals.

"I don't know exactly where the amphibole disappears in there, but it certainly decreases between Upson and Ironwood," he said, cautioning that it could still be found in smaller veins across the entire range.

Fitz said more research is needed to determine what affect mining in the Penokee Hills could have on public health.

In two weeks, about 20 samples from across the Penokees will be analyzed at the U.S. Geological Survey's Microbeam Lab in Denver. Fitz said the tests will determine the exact minerals in the bedrock.

"Some of these things are dangerous and some are not. It depends upon which mineral it is," he said. "Iron is one of the things that make them hazardous. The long skinny ones in the iron formations are iron-rich, so there's definitely reason to think that these things would be a problem in the lungs."

Fitz said he plans to present his findings at an upcoming conference on the presence of asbestos-like fibers in the Upper Midwest in October. The incidence of naturally occurring asbestos has been a growing field of interest among researchers, he said.

Fitz cited a report released by the University of Minnesota on Iron Range taconite workers in December. The findings of the health study revealed those who spend more time in the mining industry are at an increased risk of developing mesothelioma - but stopped short of finding a precise source of the problem.

The geoscientist said he may also share early results of soil samples taken from one site within the area that Gogebic Taconite planned to mine, near Ballou Creek. He's started collecting samples to confirm whether asbestos-like fibers are present in the soil.

"The bedrock isn't really a risk if it isn't disturbed, but the soils are much more easily disturbed by traffic. That's what we really interact with much more on a regular basis, is the soils at the surface. So, we need to know if it's in the soils, as well," he said.

Fitz said it's unclear whether soils at the site would contain asbestos-like fibers because of past glacial activity in the Penokee Hills.

Wisconsin Public Radio can be heard locally on 91.3 KUWS-FM and online at