Dave Hoops column: Is it OK to send tap beer back?

My intention is to highlight reasons a beer may be unacceptable and provide tools and reasons to ask for a replacement.

A glass if filled with a strawberry beer at Canal Park Brewing in Duluth. Columnist Dave Hoops explains best practices for sending back a tap beer.
Steve Kuchera / 2017 file / Duluth News Tribune

Last month I was excited to talk about warmer temps and less winter. As we all know, winter will not go quietly and seems determined to set a new historical snowfall total before it leaves us, so be it. The sun will still grace us.

I have been asked to pen a column with this topic many times. I’m writing now from a consumer’s perspective. With the current post-pandemic tap options having exploded in scope and variety, sometimes there is confusion about basic tap beer best practices and consumers’ taste preferences.

Dave Hoops
Dave Hoops

I think of the example of wine by the glass. Very few folks would hesitate to return a corked or oxidized wine served at their table. This is very acceptable and not rare. Returning said wine due to drinker dislike is a no-no and not at all common.

Beer falls into the same category. If you order a beer that is well-made and served correctly, yet you dislike it, then maybe see if any tablemates might enjoy it, as this is not a reason to ask for a replacement and doing so will vary in success rate. My intention is to highlight reasons a beer may be unacceptable and provide tools and reasons to ask for a replacement.

Dane Breimhorst
Burning Brothers Brewing co-owner Dane Breimhorst hands over a sample at the All Pints North beer festival in Duluth in 2018.
Tyler Schank / File / Duluth News Tribune


Beer is wrong

If you order a light lager and get a fruit beer, or an IPA and get a stout, by all means send it back and ask for the beer you ordered. This is more of a customer service issue and probably a simple mistake that’s easy to fix.

As we run a beer hall with beer service to the table, this topic is discussed and trained all the time, as I’m sure most establishments practice.

Temperature is wrong

Warm draft beer generally doesn’t pour well, so the problem is usually taken care of quickly. Beer should be poured at 36-38 degrees and variations on both sides do happen.

American light lager is often poured ice-cold, sometimes in a frosty glass. This removes almost all flavor and taste from the beer and the drinker can simply wait a few minutes for warm-up.

Some darker beers are served warmer, closer to 40 degrees; this brings the flavors out. This is usually not worth returning the beer.

more by dave
The perfect pairings for May and beyond.
Maibock, pilsner, golden ale, Belgian wheat styles, fruit beers, light beers, Saison and Kolsch are among popular releases this time of the year.
At the start of each New Year, I do some thinking about what’s coming next in the beer world. I do this to stay ahead on trends, mull over new ideas I like, and plan what I want to focus on.
We are lucky and fortunate to live here and enjoy the hard work of the women and men that show up every day. There has never been a better time to enjoy very high-level crafted offerings than now.
The last 15 years have supported brewery growth not seen since post-prohibition. ... It was a banner time for us and the beer-drinking public.
This week, as we head into fall and inevitably winter, I’m going to touch on some classic and newer beer styles that I’ve been a fan of and a brewer of over the years.

Bad pour

If you’re served an overly heady beer, you have a right to ask for it to be topped off and it becomes apparent that you paid for 16 ounces of beer and only ended up with 12. Foam takes up about four times as much space as beer, and you’ve got every reason to ask for a top-off.

No head on a beer is also a mistake, as the 1 inch of foam helps with eye appeal and aroma appeal before the beer gets in your mouth.


John Tobin and Matt Caple serve Warrior Brewing Company beer
John Tobin, left, and Matt Caple, owners of Warrior Brewing Co. in Duluth, serve beer at the All Pints North festival July 30, 2022, at Bayfront Festival Park.
Laura Butterbrodt / File / Duluth News Tribune


This problem arrives from old beer or beer stored warm. The flavor will be papery and stale. Politely asking for a different beer should be accommodated with a smile.

Faucet contamination

A beer should never be served if the faucet has entered the glass and submerged in the beer. It’s totally unsanitary, against draught-pour regulations and just dirty, so, yes, send it back and ask for a proper pour.

Scratched, dirty or chipped glass

Send it back as soon as you notice. If that’s not until you’re two-thirds of the way through your pint, a reputable establishment will fix this with a replacement. I dislike shaker pint glasses (the 16-ounce straight-sided glasses) for a variety of reasons and use English nonic 20-ounce and 10-ounce glasses that cannot be stacked, as stacking creates internal scratches that cause foaming and bubbling.

Erin and Matt Glesner have been working to fill in the void in Duluth's gaming scene.
The new wine and spirit bar with 'speakeasy' vibes opened earlier this year.
Shrimp po'boys and Cajun shrimp tacos are coming soon to the Rambler.
My tuna sandwich came out as a turkey sandwich, and I've no regrets.
The Canal Park restaurant is operating at half-staff with no servers.
Wrapped in a quality corn tortilla, the birria comes with beef brisket, onions and cilantro, and is spotted with hefty, melted shards of Oaxaca cheese.
The new site in the heart of Canal Park will open Memorial Day weekend.
The burger boasts two-thirds of a pound of quality, juicy beef. After a second to plan my route, I dug in.
Take your pick from salted maple granola with seasonal fruit compote to an egg and bacon sandwich with aioli on a toasted baguette.
A vote is anticipated by mid-May on whether to unionize, with an "overwhelming majority" of support among staff.

Something in the beer

Self-explanatory. Send it back.

Infected lines of beer

This is my main concern with beer off-flavors. Bars should clean the beer lines regularly and inspect the line connections as well as taste the beer when it is tapped. If this is not done, beer will taste bad. Infected beer that’s improperly brewed will also taste bad.

Unlike if there is an infection or bacteria in food, infected beer is unlikely to harm you, however, it can be very unpleasant to drink. Some common off-flavors that are easy to detect are vegetable flavors, staleness, cardboard flavors, buttery popcorn or sourness in a beer that is not supposed to be sour. Some of these off-flavors can be very obvious and any sort of quality control should weed these beers out before they are served to the public, but, unfortunately, sometimes things slip through the cracks.


While sending back a beer because it is infected is encouraged, staying pleasant and not trying to explain in too much detail how the bar is messing up is my advice. The risk of sounding like a jerk if you start throwing words like “acetaldehyde” or “diacetyl” at a busy server or bartender is not the goal. Just describe what you’re tasting and tell them it’s off. They’ll probably just replace your beer and hopefully tell management.

All of us in the service industry strive to provide a quality experience and product. I hope this column can help shed light on a topic that is not discussed as much as I think it should be.

Please email any comments or questions. Happy spring.

Dave Hoops, who lives and works in Duluth, is a veteran brewer and beer judge. Have a beer-related question for Dave? Email him at or the News Tribune at

More by News Tribune columnists
I would feel terrible saying goodbye to my current ladder, but of course, at my age I have parted with several ladders.
Retired teacher Larry Weber, of Barnum, is the author of “Butterflies of the North Woods" and “Spiders of the North Woods," among other books. Reach him via Katie Rohman at
A calendar of naked-eye and binocular highlights to start your summer.
I was so embarrassed to get hearing aids in my 30s. I was so worried about what people would think of me. But do you know what I’ve found?
The Red Planet will cross directly in front of one the sky's most iconic star clusters this week. Watch it happen in binoculars.

Dave Hoops lives and works in Duluth and is a veteran brewer and beer judge.
What To Read Next
Get Local