Excavators and bulldozers have been moving dirt and plenty of it lately at the corner of Haines and Arrowhead roads in Duluth, where a new Costco store is expected to open by fall 2021.
But money began to move before the dirt did. It will take $2 million in public subsidies to bring the new 160,000-square-foot retail warehouse onto the scene in Duluth. Earlier this summer, the Duluth City Council unanimously agreed to forgo $1.35 million in property taxes, and St. Louis County followed suit with another $650,000 of property tax relief.
That may sound like a lot of money, but it's not uncommon for would-be host communities to court Costco with the promise of significant public assistance:
- Springfield, Missouri, expects to provide Costco with about $4.8 million in sales tax rebates at a new store slated to open in 2021.
Naperville, Illinois, approved up to $5.5 million in sales tax rebates to bring a second Costco to town earlier this year.
Georgetown and Midland, Texas, partnered to offer Costco about $11 million in tax incentives to bring a store to their market.
University City, Missouri, is prepared to provide up to $70 million in tax-increment financing to support a retail development with a Costco anchor expected to open in 2021.
Costco did not respond to the News Tribune's request for comment about the role public subsidies have played in growing the company's footprint.
But Mike Stratis, who helps Costco with site selection as vice president and counsel for Intrepid Properties Inc., offered some perspective.
"Costco applies a moral approach in the pursuit of municipal incentives — in short, we request community assistance only when we need it, have demonstrated openly what the gap is, why it exists and have further offered up alternatives for reducing or eliminating it," he said.
At large Duluth City Councilor Arik Forsman said that any time the city considers employing tax incentives, it needs to approach the matter in a judicious fashion.
"You are trading something of value to our city and our taxpayers in exchange for incentivizing a business to locate in town," he said.
Forsman said Costco isn't a typical big-box store in that it is expected to have a very broad "catchment radius," drawing customers from throughout the Northland and parts of Canada, if and when pandemic border controls are loosened.
"One of the criticisms you could levy against using TIF (tax-increment financing) or tax abatement for big-box development is that either you are incentivizing a competitor of your existing large businesses that are in town or that you are incentivizing a large business at the expense of your smaller businesses," he said.
But Forsman believes Costco has the ability to grow the retail sales pie in Duluth rather than just carving up existing business and redistributing it.
"They are going to help attract new customers to Duluth that would not be here without a Costco or who would not be spending their money for certain things in Duluth without a Costco. So, that helps alleviate concerns that you're just replacing one thing for another that you would otherwise be benefiting from. That wouldn't make any sense," he said.
At large City Councilor Zack Filipovich draws another distinction between Costco and other big-box retailers.
"They have higher-than-average pay. Their employees seem to rate them highly. And I think that is an important piece, at least to me, when we're talking about some of these economic development tools that we're able to leverage," Filipovich said.
Even with the tax abatement package in place, Duluth Chief Administrative Officer Noah Schuchman expects the new Costco to generate more than enough local sales tax revenue to offset the property tax break it will receive. While the retailer stands to save about $85,000 in property taxes its first year, the store is expected to yield about $200,000 in local sales tax revenue for the city.
"That's a very, very strong argument for the project and for the tax abatement that we're providing to get Costco into Duluth," Filipovich said.
"It's important that we have Costco specifically in Duluth to help drive our tax base and increase resources here in the city," he said. "And after the abatement is paid off, then we will have that property tax base increase, as well."
Adam Fulton, Duluth's deputy director of planning and economic development, said Duluth typically hasn't used tax incentives to support retail development. But it's not unprecedented. He noted that tax-increment financing played a role in redeveloping the Spirit Valley Mall area after a new freeway plowed its way through that neighborhood. Likewise, he pointed to the renovation of the Fitger's Brewery Complex.
He said those dollars were used primarily for public infrastructure improvements that set the stage for development, just as they will at the Costco site to support that project and possibly others in the future.
"We would not have been able to proceed with the infrastructure investment without that development happening, and often the developers tell us that if the infrastructure improvements don't happen, they can't do their projects," Fulton said.
"In an ideal world, perhaps we would have the projects pay for all the public infrastructure. But near Costco, for example, you have several county roads, and you have a major traffic artery serving the Duluth International Airport. So, we'd need to have a very sound transportation system up there whether there's a Costco on that corner or not," he said.
"Part of what we're looking at is the broader impacts to the community here and the needed infrastructure investments, paired with other things that relate to that project, such as the creation of additional sales tax for the city," Fulton said.
But critics of public subsidies for large retailers question suggest tax giveaways to huge retailers needlessly deprive communities of valuable resources.
"What this does is privileges large companies at the expense of smaller local independent businesses," said Ron Knox, a senior researcher for the Institute for Local Self-Reliance, noting that small businesses provide the lion's share of jobs and also support local supply lines, unlike massive national retail chains, such as Costco.
"Unfortunately, communities tend to spend their local taxpayer dollars where they are least needed, which is on multi-million, often multi-billion-dollar national and international corporations," Knox said. "They don't need the money. If Costco wants to come into a community, it's because Costco thinks that that community can support that Costco. There's no other reason for them to do it.
"This is capitalism. If they think they're going to make money somewhere, then a Costco is going to move there," Knox said. "They do not need a public handout in order to do so."
Forsman said public funds were needed to overcome development challenges.
"There's a reason that site hadn't been developed before," he said. "You see the mountain of earthwork that's on it right now. You can tell there's a lot of work that's been done already. It was not a flat pad, ready for something to be built on top of it."
Abated property tax proceeds will go to cover a number of project costs in Duluth, including roadway improvements, turning lanes, signals, sidewalks, a watermain extension and blasting of hard rock formations on site.
"Sometimes you're just trying to close a gap that is legitimate, that is something that solves a long-term challenge and oftentimes it comes from the infrastructure extensions and the sitework. And I think you've got both of those things that came into play here," Forsman said.
Filipovich views the aid as a necessary ingredient.
"It's important for folks to realize that it's not just a cash giveaway," he said. "We're estimating the future value of these taxable pieces of property, and without this kind of gap funding that TIF and tax abatement provide, that project would not come about. "
Forsman said Costco's board of directors is understandably focused on maximizing the company's return on investment, and cities that can make a more compelling case will prevail.
"That is part of the cost of doing business," he said.
As for whether Duluth considered the competitive landscape and the incentives Costco was accustomed to receiving, Fulton said: "Our analysis did not dive deep into that aspect of their proposal."
"We were not out recruiting to get Costco to come to Duluth," he said, explaining that the city was instead working with the company to find an appropriate site after the retailer expressed interest in opening a Duluth store. From that point on, Fulton said, city staff focused on determining whether the request for site-specific aid was reasonable and necessary to make the project move forward.
This story was updated at 5:25 p.m. Nov. 24 with quotes from Mike Stratis, vice president and legal counsel for Intrepid Properties Inc. It was originally posted at 7:59 a.m. Nov. 24.